Massachusetts Insurance Commissioner Michael Caljouw has rejected an industry proposal to raise workers’ compensation rates by 7.1%.
As a result, existing rates, which reflect a 14.6% decrease ordered last July, will remain in effect for policies on and after July 1, 2025.
The ruling is a setback for the industry’s rate filing organization, the Workers’ Compensation Rating and Inspection Bureau (WCRIB), which criticized last year’s decrease as “excessive” and “unreasonable.” The 2024 reduction was nearly double what the WCRIB recommended (-7.6%) for a cut.
WCRIB warned that the 2024 decrease would lead to rates that would be inadequate as further post-COVID pandemic data emerged. The rate organization said that if the state had approved the 7.6% decrease it proposed for 2024, this year’s rate filing would have been for a relatively small rate decrease of 1.0%.
Massachusetts Weighs Workers’ Comp Rate Hike to Correct for ‘Excessive’ 2024 Cut
“Thus, rather than being able to maintain a more modest rate decrease for two years, the data now points to a rate increase to correct for the excessive decrease ordered” by the commissioner for 2024, the rating agency argued.
Despite the warning, the state has now rejected the WCRIB filing made in December for a 7.1% increase starting July 1, 2025.
State officials said the denial of the 7.1% increase could save employers $80 million, while last year’s decrease saved $87 million.
The rate approval process includes hearings with testimony from WCRIB, the Division of Insurance’s own rating bureau, and the attorney general’s office. This year the attorney general recommended an average rate decrease of -6.2 % and the state rating bureau proposed a decrease for standard classifications of between -3.1 and -2.1%, and between -7.6% and -6.7% for the F-classes.
