Year over year, average U.S. commercial premium renewals for all major commercial lines of business are up except for workers’ compensation, according to the Ivans Index.
Chicago-based Ivans recently released its latest index results, with commercial auto, busin
ess owners policy, general liability, commercial property and umbrella seeing increased average premium renewal rates for October, but less than the prior month.
The findings draw on more than 120 million insurance transactions across the U.S. market, and includes more than 38,000 agencies and 700 carriers and managing general agents.
Premium renewal rate change by line of business for October 2026 highlights include:
Commercial Auto: 2.80%, down from 3.29% at the end of September.
BOP: 5.21%, down from 5.45% last month.
General Liability: 3.10%
, down slightly from 3.19% in September.
Commercial Property: 5.37%, up from 5.11% last month.
Umbrella: 6.08%, down fr
om 6.40% in September.
Workers’ Compensation: -1.4
See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>
5%, down from -1.14% last month.
Looking at results from the thi
rd quarter 2026, all major lines of business saw a decrease in average premium renewal rate change compared with the prior quarter, except workers’ comp, which saw a slight increase.
For commercial auto, Q3 average premium renewal rate averaged 3.63%, a decrease compared to Q2’s average premium renewal rate of 4.93%. Commercia
l auto rate increases at renewal have been trending down since April 20
26. Rate renewals averages 7.6% in Q3 2025, said Applied System’s Ivans.
Average premium renewal rate change for commercial property experienced a decrease during Q3 2026 of 5.65% compared with 6.40% in Q2. Rates were up 7.64% in Q3 2025.
Florida is suing the climate-risk modeling firm First Street Technology Inc., accusing it of penalizing state homeowners with risk scores based on flawed science.
Filed Oct. 23, the lawsuit highlights growing pushback against the scores, which are intended to give consumers more insight into homes’ exposure to fir
e, flood and other climate-related dangers. Nebraska brought its own, similar suit against the company in August.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, a Republican who is running for reelection, said when announcing the action on X that First Street data is inaccura
te and “homeowners deserve facts, not alarmist scores that hit their property values and their wallets.”
First Street, which was recently acquired by MSCI Inc., uses computer models to estimate the threat to property of flooding, wildfire, extreme heat, wind and other hazards — now and decades into the future — down to the level of an individual address.
MSCI didn’t respond to a request for comment.
Other companies model those risks, but First Street turns the estimates into 1-to-10 scores and makes them widely available through real-estate websites. The idea is to make transparent the climate-related risks to property and support informed purchasing decisions.
After First Street produced its first major report in 2020, real-estate sites including Zillow, Redfin and Realtor.com started integrating its risk scores. Connecticut’s state insurance department even partnered with the company to offer residents free assessments of their properties.






































