California Group Off the Hook for Defamation Suit Brought by Maine Lobster Industry

 The First Circuit Court of Appeals has dismissed a defamation lawsuit by Maine lobster interests against a California environmental group that urged the pu


Acc-2 Acc-1 Acc-3 Acc-4 Acc-5 Acc-10 Acc-11


blic to avoid eating North American lobster because, the group alleged, lobster fishing poses a risk to an endangered whale.


Acc-12 Acc-13 Acc-14 Acc-19 Acc-20 Acc-21

The court ruled that because the statements by the nonprofit Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation did not specifically target the five lobster industry plaintiffs, their lawsuit was barred by the group defamation rule.


Three Maine lobster fishing companies and two associations maintained that the statements by Aquarium were inaccurate as to their fishing methods and harmful to each of them. They argued that other fishing industries pose a greater risk to rare whales than lobstering.


Acc-22 Acc-23 Acc-28 Acc-29 Acc-30 Acc-31 Acc-32

In the federal district court for Maine, Aquarium moved to dismiss the case on the grounds that the group defamation rule barred the plaintiffs’ claims under Main


e law. Under this rule, a defamatory statement about a large group is not actionable unless the statement or its context indicates that it is targeted at specific members of the group.


Acc-37 Acc-38 Acc-39 Acc-40 Acc-41 Acc-46 Acc-47 Acc-48 Acc-49 Acc-50

The lower court denied Aquarium’s request to dismiss and allowed the plaintiffs’ action to go forward. The district court concluded that Aquarium’s statements applied equally to each plaintiff as required by the group defamation rule.


However, the First Circuit appeals court has now disagreed with the district court’s application of the group defamation rule and reversed. While there is an except


Watch More Image Part 2 >>>

ion to the group defamation rule’s ban on lawsuits where the alleged defamatory statements reference particular parties, the First Circuit found that the lobster industr


y plaintiffs failed to satisfy this exception by establishing that the statements were “of and concerning” them.


The five plaintiffs that brought the defamation suit are Bean Maine Lobster, Inc., a company that “markets and sells high-quality mid-coast Maine-caught lobster


and lobster foods”; the Maine Lobstermen’s Association, Inc., a nonprofit “that represents roughly 1,200 of Maine’s 5,600 lobstermen”; the Maine C


oast Fishermen’s Association, Inc., a nonprofit “that works to enhance the sustainability of Maine’s fisheries” and “advocates for the needs of community-based fishermen”; (4) Maine Lobster and Processing, LLC, “a third-gene


ration Maine lobster company and . . . one of the leading lobster producers in the United States”; and Bug Catcher, Inc., “a lobster fishing company” in Maine run by “a sixth-generation lobsterman.”


For many years, Aquarium has raised concerns about the impact of fishing on the North Atlantic right whale. According to Aquarium, one threat to the whale is the risk of entanglement in fishing gear, including the buoy lines lobstermen use to mark the placement of their lobster traps.


In the last decade, the Maine lobster industry has implemented changes to its fishing practices to protect whales. The industry has decreased the amount of rope in the water, created more exacting requirements for weak links,


weak rope and break-aways to weaken vertical fishing lines, and closed nearly 1,000 square miles of fishing grounds for an entire season each year.”


Nevertheless, in September 2022, Aquarium issued a press release announcing that it had assigned “red ratings” (meaning consumers should “avoid” the seafood) because of the “dire risk to the endangered North Atlantic right whale” posed by the fisheries. The press release stated that the red ratings were based on “significant risks of entanglement in pot,


trap, and gillnet fisheries to the endangered North Atlantic right whale and the lack of timely, effective management necessary to mitigate entanglement risks and promote recovery of the species.”

Đăng nhận xét

Mới hơn Cũ hơn

Support me!!! Thanks you!