Town Appeals Denial of Insurance for $11M Judgment Over Political Closing of Quarry

 The Connecticut town of East Haven is appealing a federal district court ruling that rejected its claim for insurance coverage for a civil lawsuit and $11 million judg


XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-030 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-031 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-032 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-033 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-034 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-035


ment against it regarding the closure of a local quarry in 2017 for political reasons.


XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-036 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-037 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-038 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-039 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-040 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-041 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-042

The $11 million was awarded to quarry owners who alleged that the town interfered with their operations through various regulatory measures before eventually shutting it down through a series of cease-and-desist order


s in 2017. The quarry owners sought damages in excess of $25 million for actions by the town and its officials they say violated their federal and state constitutional rights.


XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-043 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-044 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-045 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-046 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-047 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-048 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-049 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-050 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-051 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-052

The town had two different liability insurers, Starr Indemnity and Liability, and Allied World Insurance. Both insurers disclaimed duties to defend and indemnify the town for the quarry owners’ civil case under the terms of their policies.


The town sued to force the insurers to defend and indemnify it for the quarry owners’ lawsuit. In September, the federal district court for Connecticut granted summary judgment to the two insurers. The district court found that


XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-053 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-054 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-055 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-056 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-057 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-058 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-059 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-060 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-061 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-062 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-063 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-064 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-065 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-066 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-067 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-068 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-069 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-070 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-071 XIUREN-No-3607-Zhang-Xin-Xin-Mr-Cong-com-072

neither insurer breached a duty to indemnify or defend. In the case of Starr, the actions taken by the officials that closed the quarry were taken outside of the policy period. In A


llied World’s case, an exclusion for claims related to the “lack of due process” barred coverage.


See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>


On October 21, the town informed the court it would be appealing that district court decision and the final judgement to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.


The underlying action brought against the town, former Mayor Joseph Maturo, Jr., a zoning official and the town tax assessor by the quarry was filed in June 201


7. The plaintiffs were John Patton, One Barberry Real Estate Holding, LLC and Farm River Rock LLC, who owned and operated a quarry in East Haven.


According to their complaint, the town’s actions included reclassifying portions of the quarry as industrial land and taxing it at a higher rate than previo


usly beginning in October 2015; informing Patton that blasting permits would not be granted in the months preceding the 2015 municipal election; and issu


ing three cease-and-desist orders between February and May 2017, t


he last of which instructed the owners to completely shut down their quarry operations.


A federal judge in a bench trial concluded that the town and officials infringed on the quarry owners’ constitutionally protected property right in an arbitrary and irrational manner, in violation of their Fourteenth Amendment


substantive due process protections. The judge awarded damages of $9,465,832. The quarry owners moved to alter the judgment and were granted prejudgment interest and


attorneys’ fees and costs, bringing the total to $11,000,000.

Đăng nhận xét

Mới hơn Cũ hơn

Support me!!! Thanks you!