The surplus lines and specialty commercial markets are becoming an increasingly competitive space, with supply outweighing demand in some lines of coverage and risk classes creating “micro-market” trends not experienced in previous softer markets.
AM Best reported in its recently released State of the Market report that there remains an “abundance of capital and heightened competition among ins
urers, reinsurers, and managing general agents (MGAs),” which is shifting the landscape to a policyholder’s market when it comes to negotiating power. “More than a
mple market capacity–from insurers, reinsurers, and delegated underwriting authority enterprises (DUAEs) such as MGAs and program managers–is outpacing demand and pressuring margins,” the report said.
But the competitive landscape is not reducing surplus lines’ piece of the commercial lines pie. Even with rapidly softening rates in the property market, surplus l
ines carriers represented 27.5% of the U.S. commercial insurance market in 2025, up from 25.7% in 2024, AM Best noted. That percentage first broke the 20% marker in 2021 and has increased successively each year.
While insurance market cycle history would tell that now is the time to prepare for retreat of business into the admitted market, this historical trend may now be gone forever.
Compared to historical business cycles, the enhanced importance of surplus lines intermediaries will negate any broad, rapid retreat from the surplus lines market
See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>
as admitted carriers seek opportunities to grow their portfolios, AM Best believes. Also, most carriers now own and operate their own excess and surplus (E&S) entity, allow
ing them to rebalance exposures across their admitted and non-admitted divisions as market conditions evolve and dictate.
Today’s surplus lines market is not the same as it was in past soft markets, said Tim Turner, CEO of Ryan Specialty and chairman of Ryan Turner Specialty, Ryan Specialty’s wholesale brokerage division.
“This cycle is very different and unique for a number of reasons,” he said. The overall market has been completely restructured. “In the last soft market, 15 years ago, there were less than a dozen wholesale dedicated insurance co
mpanies,” Turner said. “Today, there’s 110, and most large, admitted companies now own an E&S company, too,” he added. That change limits the “gravitational pull from
admitted companies” to take business back into the admitted-only market, he explained. “We just don’t see that today, and that gives the E&S market long-term stability.”







































