The Pennsylvania Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the state’s $250,000 damages cap on claims against state agencies, turning aside arguments that the cap that was set in 1978 violates both the right to a jury trial and right to a remedy guaranteed by the state Constitution, even where the injured party may end up with little or nothing.
The high court majority affirmed that the legislature has the authority to set a cap on the state’s liability while also acknowledging three consenting opinions that appeal to the legislature to update the damages cap. The high court declined to substitute its judgment of what the cap should be for that of lawmakers.
The ruling came in a case of Hayley Freilich who sustained catastrophic, life-altering injuries when she was hit by a Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) bus. Freilich required a partial amputation of her left foot, skin grafts, and tendon lengthening surgeries and suffers from permanent nerve damage and will require lifelong medical care.
SEPTA admitted negligence and, due to COVID-19 conditions at the time, the parties entered into a stipulated jury verdict totaling $7 million ($1 million for economic losses and $6 million for non-economic damages). The
reafter, in accordance with the Sovereign Immunity Act, the trial court reduced the $7 million verdict to the statutory cap of $250,000. The sovereign immunity
doctrine holds that the Commonwealth cannot be sued in its own courts except with its consent and insulates the Commonwealth and its agencies from liability except in specified circumstances when that consent is granted.
Shrinking Value
Freilich opposed reducing the damages to the $250,000 amount in the immunity act, pointing ou
t that would leave her with zero financial recovery because legal fees, medical costs and insurer reimbursements would take all of it and more.
See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>
Freilich argued that the damages cap is unconstitutional as applied to her because it “renders cost-prohibitive the exercise of her right to a jury trial” in light of the realiti
es of litigating a catastrophic injury case against the Commonwealth. Freilich also pointed out that the real value of the cap has been shrinking each year, increasingly shifting the burden of paying for accidents caused by the Commonwealth onto tort victims.
SEPTA defended the cap as a constitutional act of the legislature. SEPTA argued that the legislature eliminated jury trials in contract claims against the Commonwealth and channeled such actions through the Board of Claims.
But assuming such a right exists, SEPTA maintained, a statutory cap on damages does not impose the kind of “onerous burden” that impedes the jury trial right, rather it merely imposes a limit on the right to recovery post-verdict.
Both the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas and the Commonwealth Court sided with SEPTA and the damages cap. They cited a 2014 Supreme Court ca
se (Zauflik v. Pennsbury School District), which rejected a similar claim that a statutory damages cap violated the right to a jury trial. That decision found that the right to a jury trial involves a process and the damages cap does not curtail that right.
















































