The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance has ordered GEICO to return more than $10.5 million in wrongfully-charged premium back to policyholders.
The department also issued a penalty of $1.2 million to GEICO and its affiliates for improper business practices.
The returned premiums and penalty are the result of a market conduct exam that covered GEICO’s private passenger automobile insurance business durin
g the period June 1, 2023 to May 31, 2024 in response to consumer complaints. During the course of the examination, the department identified what it called a “syst
emic pattern of improper practices” affecting more than 15,000 policyholders across multiple GEICO companies.
The department’s examination cited the company in four areas: charging rates higher than what were previously approved by the department; cancelling policies for improper reasons; failing to disclose required lang
uage on notices that could lead to policy nonrenewal; and failing to make total loss vehicle owners who retain the vehicle after settlement aware of their rights.
The department said GEICO voluntarily began issuing refunds during the examination process as the errors were identified.
Watch More Image Part 2 >>>
A Zurich adjuster determined that the loss was due to water damage, not flooding, and Zurich s
ent advance payments totaling $600,000 for the first three rainfall events. The policy allowed a $100,000 per-event deductible for water damage.
But Zurich then reversed course, arguing that the deluges in 2019 and 2020 were actually flood events. In the policy, flood damage carried a much higher ded
uctible—$2.5 million per event. That meant that all of the claimed damage was below the First Solar policy deductible and no payout was due, Zurich argued, as the court explained.
Litigation ensued. After a jury in the U.S. District Court in the Middle District of Georgia found in
favor of First Solar, the judge awarded $12.2 million, including prejudgment interest.
Both sides appealed parts of the decision.
A key question was the wording of the policy. Water damage was defined as “all damage caused by water, whatever the source, whether or not driven by win
d, other than that otherwise defined as flood or that resulting from a named storm.”




















