In the long-simmering clash between property insurers and public adjusters, the adjusters now have Florida’s chief law enforcement officer on their side, after
state Attorney General James Uthmeier announced his office will investigate anti-public adjuster endorsements in some Florida insurance policies.
Uthmeier, now in a tight race against Democrat Jose Javier Rodriguez, announced Tuesday, Oct. 21, that his staff has subpoenaed docum
ents from Velocity Risk Underwriters, a Ryan Specialty managing general agent. A civil lawsuit against Velocity, brought by public adjusters over the same issue, is now pending in Miami-Dade Circuit Court.
“We are looking into whether Velocity and other insurance companies worked together to ban public adjusters so they could pay out less money,” Uthm
eier said in a news release. “Insurance companies use their own adjusters. Homeowners should be allowed to hire an advocate on their side too.”
Uthmeier stated flatly, without attribution: “Homeowners who use a public adjuster can receive up to 30 percent more money on their claims than those who do not.”
He may have been referencing a 2010 study from the Florida Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability, which examined Citizens Property
See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>
Insurance claims from 2004 and 2005. The report noted that catastrophe claims with public adjuster involvement took four times as long to settle, and that the “typical” PA-involved claim payout was 19% higher in 2004 and 747% higher in 2005.
A Velocity Risk spokesperson said in an email that the firm is cooperating with the AG’s office and is confident of a favorable outcome.
Uthmeier may be barking up the wrong tree: Velocity Risk does not write homeowners’ policies in Florida.
“Velocity’s non-admitted, surplus lines property policies containing this endorsement are issued to commercial insureds and it does not place personal residential homeowners’ insurance policies in Florida, which is the focus of the investigation by the Attorney General’s office,” the company noted.
Velocity’s policies for commercial property in the state are in accordance with the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, which has previously approved the inclusion of a similar anti-public adjuster endorsement to admi
tted policies for Florida homeowners who accept it for reduced premiums, the statement added
One Florida insurance executive called Uthmeier’s words “surprising,” given that Uthmeier was appointed by Gov. Ron DeSantis, who has publicly supported measures to curb public adjusters’ aggressive solicitation efforts of homeowners.
The attorney general’s statement also is a far cry from those of former Florida Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis, now a member of Congress, who often railed about public adjusters swooping in after hurricanes and exagger
ating damage amounts in claims. Patronis and his successor, current CFO Blaise Ingoglia also have brought charges against several public adjusters in recent years for fraud and theft.
But Florida property insurance advocates suggested that it’s all about politics: Uthmeier may be hoping to gain favor with consumers two weeks before the Nov. 3 election. One recent poll in September showed Uthmeier in a virtual
dead heat with Rodriguez, Florida Politics reported. A James Madison Institute poll, released Oct. 9, showed Uthmeier ahead, 50% to 40%. Rodriquez has pledged to seek more aggressive oversight of property insurers and to make the AG’s office an advocate in court for policyholders, according to news reports and the Rodriguez campaign.



































