An Alabama insurance agent is in the clear after years of litigation that contended he had failed to secure professional liability coverage for a pharmacy that was sued over a compounded medication error.
The reason: Alabama courts, more than some states’ courts, have endorsed the concept of contributory negligence in many cases. The Alabama pharmacy owner had contributed to the oversight by failing to carefully read his
own insurance policy, the Alabama Supreme Court said in a recent opinion in OMS Pharmacy v. Nationwide and Baldo-Downs Insurance agency and Roger Downs.
“Alabama has a very favorable standard for agents and brokers,” said Robert Ronnlund, the attorney for the insurance agency in the appeal. “Unquestionably, there co
uld be other states that would not find this as favorably as Alabama was compelled to do, given these circumstances.”
“…We agree with the trial court that OMS did not offer substantial evidence demonstrating that Downs or the agency defendants acted or failed to act while being c
Watch More Image Part 2 >>>
onscious that injury to OMS would likely or probably result,” the court’s Oct. 9 opinion concluded.
The suit against Nationwide and Baldo-Downs Insurance, a Tuscaloosa agency, and Roger Downs, the head of the predecessor agency, stemmed from a near
ly $5 million judgment against OMS Pharmacy. Customer Hannah Browne said she was severely injured in 2013 after the pharmacy produced a prescribed drug cocktail for stomach pain.
The compounded pink liquid included belladonna, also known as deadly nightshade, a poisonous plant. In small doses, the substance can treat a number of conditi
ons, including stomach pain. Unfortunately, the court noted, a technician at the Tuscaloosa pharm
acy had entered grams instead of milligrams into the store’s computer system, resulting in a formulation that was 1,000 stronger and more toxic than what the doctor had prescribed.
After one tablespoon, Browne suffered belladonna poisoning, with nausea, hallucinations, and convulsions. She became unresponsive and was rushed to intensive care at a local hospital. A few months later, she filed suit against O
MS Pharmacy and owner Timothy Wright, claiming negligence and product liability.
A jury awarded Browne $4.75 million in damages.
Roger Downs, the insurance agent and head of Roger Downs Inc. insurance agency at the time, in 2008 had obtained a general liability policy for the pharmacy throug
h Nationwide Property and Casualty Insurance, switching the store from its previous policy with Zurich American Insurance.
After the belladonna injury, Nationwide declined to defend the pharmacy in the lawsuit, pointing out that it had written only a general liability policy, not pro
fessional liability coverage. The GL policy, in fact, contained an exclusion for injuries caused by pro
fessional services. The previous Zurich policy was also general liability but did contain a clause that provided coverage for “pharmacological services.”
















