The biggest tech companies are warring over who’s responsible for children’s safety online, with billions of dues
llars in fines on the line as states rapidly pass conflicting laws requiring companies to verify users’ ages.
The struggle has turned into a struggle that’s pitted Meta Platforms Inc. and other app developers ag
ainst Apple Inc. and Alphabet Inc.’s Google, the world’s largest app stores. Lobbyists for both sides are moving from
state to state, working to water down or redirect the legislation to minimize their clients' risks.
This year alone, at least three states — Utah, Texas and Lou
isiana — passed legislation requiring tech companies to authenticate users’ ages, secure parental consent for anyone under 18 and ensure minors are protected f
rom potentially harmful digital experiences. Now, lobbyists for all three companies are flooding into South Carolina and
Ohio, the next possible states to consider such legislation.
The debate has taken on new importance after the Supreme C
ourt this summer ruled age verification laws are constitutional in some instances. A tech group on Wednesday petitioned th
e Supreme Court to block a social media age verification law in Mississippi, teeing up a highly consequential decision in the next few weeks.
See more beautiful photo albums Here >>>
Child advocates say holding tech companies responsible for verifying the ages of their users is key to creating a safer online experience for minors. Paren
ts and advocates have meaningful the social media platforms funnel childre
n into unsafe and toxic online spaces, exposing young people to harmful content about self harm, eating disorders, drug abuse and more.
Blame Game
Meta argues the app stores should be responsible for figuring out
Whether minors are accessing inappropriate content, comparing the app store to a liquor store that checks patrons' IDs. Apple and Google, meanwhile, argue age
verification laws violate children's privacy and argue the individual apps are better-positioned to do age checks. Apple said it’s more accurate to describe the app store as a mall and Meta as the liquor store.
The three new state laws put the responsibility on app stores, signaling Meta's arguments are gaining traction. The company lobbied in support of the Utah and Louisiana laws putting the onus on Apple and Google for tracking their users’ ages. Similar Meta-backed proposals have been introduced in 20 states. Federal legislation proposed by Republican Senator Mike Lee of Utah would hold the app stores accountable for verifying users’ ages.